New Columbus Pizza & Catering Co. – Authentic Italian Pies & Hoagies in Nesquehoning, PA

New Columbus Pizza & Catering Co., nestled in the heart of Nesquehoning, PA, is a beacon for pizza lovers and fans of authentic Italian takeout. From the moment you place an order—whether it's a specialty pie or a classic Italian hoagie—you can expect not just a meal but a comforting experience. Their online ordering system is straightforward, letting customers choose their preferred pick-up time without hassle, which speaks volumes about their customer-focused approach.

What truly sets New Columbus apart is the quality and consistency of their food. Long-time patrons like George Semko have praised them for over five decades, highlighting the place as a source of “good comfort food.” The pizza here is more than just a quick bite; it’s crafted with care, with Tony and the dedicated kitchen team ensuring each pie is a masterpiece of flavors. Whether you prefer a traditional pie or one of their specialty options, every bite delivers on that promise of warmth and satisfaction.

Customer feedback underscores the friendly service and the passion poured into every dish. Melissa L emphasizes the “fabulous” quality and the hard work of the team, while Cheryl Leibig notes the irresistible Italian hoagies alongside the pizza. Even if some tastes vary, as Thomas reflects, the overall rating leans strongly positive, suggesting a place that caters well to a broad spectrum of palates.

Despite being open only on Fridays, New Columbus Pizza & Catering Co. draws in a loyal crowd eager to savor their handcrafted, flavorful offerings. It’s this blend of tradition, quality ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes them stand out in the crowded world of pizza takeaway.